An APA refusal is not the end of a pricing-certainty strategy — but how the company reads the refusal letter decides whether plan B works. Under the advance pricing agreement mechanism in Vietnamese tax administration law (now within the frame of Tax Administration Law 108/2025/QH15, applied to related-party transactions under Decree 255/2026/ND-CP; earlier periods against Decree 132/2020/ND-CP), an APA may be unilateral (with the Vietnamese authority), bilateral or multilateral (with partner tax authorities under a treaty). The overview of the APA regime in Vietnam (FDI-LC-2052) presents the mechanism when things go smoothly; this article is for the refused or returned application, and for building plan B.
Reading the refusal: three cause groups, three different responses
Group one, scope refusal: the proposed transactions are unsuitable for an APA — for example one-off transactions, outcomes driven by uncontrollable market factors, or proposed periods overlapping an already-concluded inspection. This group leaves little room to refile the same scope; plan B is narrowing the transaction scope or redirecting effort into annual documentation. Group two, dossier refusal: information insufficient for the authority to evaluate the proposed method (missing benchmarking data, missing functional analysis, ungrounded financial forecasts). This group can be refiled after supplementing, and the refusal letter usually names the gaps.
Group three, no agreement on method: the parties engaged substantively but could not agree on the method or the value range. For a unilateral APA this is the end of the road; for two-country transactions, consider pivoting to a bilateral APA so the partner authority joins the table, and in all cases record the points that were agreed (usually the functional analysis and method selection) as the foundation for compliance files and future inspections.
Refiling, and bilateral versus unilateral
Refiling is viable where the refusal was dossier-based or where real conditions have changed (new transaction structure, new benchmarking data, changed functions). The refiled dossier must answer each point of the earlier refusal directly, with visible changes; refiling an identical dossier produces the identical result, later. On form: a unilateral APA gives one-sided (Vietnamese) certainty with a leaner procedure; a bilateral APA is slower and depends on the partner authority, but is the only form that structurally eliminates double taxation, because both authorities commit to the same method.
Under the current mechanism an APA applies for a maximum of five years and may include a rollback to pre-signing years if the parties agree and transaction conditions are comparable — the rollback request belongs in the first application, not in later supplementary negotiation.
While the APA is pending: audit risk is not frozen
A pending APA creates no audit prohibition: periods outside the proposed APA scope, and periods inside the scope but preceding APA effect without a rollback agreement, remain fully open to transfer pricing inspection. Only post-signing periods within scope are protected by the agreement. A complete plan B therefore always has two layers: continue the APA track (or refile) for the future, and strengthen annual documentation and explanation positions for all open periods as if no APA protected them.
One governance detail is often missed: during APA discussions the company hands the authority a large volume of analysis about its own transactions. That information lives in the tax administration file even if the APA fails; every document filed in the APA process must therefore be drafted on the assumption it will be used in later inspections — absolutely consistent with the corresponding years’ documentation.
FAQ
Why was the APA refused?
Refusals usually fall into three groups: the proposed transactions are unsuitable for APA scope; the dossier lacks information to evaluate the proposed method (missing benchmarking, functional analysis, forecast grounds); or the parties fail to agree on the method or value range after substantive discussion. Reading the group correctly is the precondition for plan B, because only dossier-based refusals and changed real conditions leave a genuine refile path.
Can I resubmit?
Yes, where the refusal was dossier-based or where transaction conditions and data have changed. The refiled dossier must answer each point of the earlier refusal directly and evidence the supplementation; refiling unchanged earns the same result. For scope-based refusals, narrow the scope or redirect resources into annual documentation instead.
Is bilateral or unilateral better?
It depends on the objective: a unilateral APA is leaner and gives certainty on the Vietnamese side; a bilateral APA is slower and depends on the partner authority under the treaty, but is the only form that structurally eliminates double taxation because both authorities commit to one method. Transactions with material adjustment risk at both ends should prefer bilateral.
Can I be inspected while the APA is pending?
Yes, normally. A pending APA does not freeze inspection activity: periods outside the proposed scope and periods before APA effect (without a rollback agreement) remain open to transfer pricing inspection. Keep annual documentation inspection-ready for every period the APA does not yet cover.
Related articles
- VAT on cross-border e-commerce into Vietnam
- Country-by-country reporting (CbCR): who files and deadlines
- The 3-tier TP dossier: master file, local file and CbCR
- Royalties paid to Korea: contractor tax and treaty relief
- FDI Enterprises in Vietnam: Periodic Tax Reporting Obligations
This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.

