Tax

Transfer pricing risks for FDI firms with consecutive loss years

Detailed graph showing financial data trends

An FDI company losing money for three or four straight years while still expanding its factory is the single picture that draws transfer pricing attention most — not because losses are wrong, but because an ordinary business rarely keeps funding a chronically loss-making unit unless value is leaking out somewhere through related-party prices.

What do tax authorities suspect at a chronic loss-maker?

The audit hypothesis usually has three branches. First, revenue is siphoned out: sales prices to related parties below market, or sales routed through a related distributor that keeps most of the chain’s profit. Second, costs are pushed in: management fees, royalties, related-party interest and input prices that look high against the functions the Vietnamese company actually performs. Third, the Vietnamese company bears mismatched risk: a toll manufacturer with low functional risk should show a stable margin, yet its books show losses — that contradiction opens most audits. Under Decree 255/2026/ND-CP (effective 1 July 2026, replacing Decrees 132/2020 and 20/2025, applying from the 2026 CIT period), the functions–assets–risks analysis is the basis on which authorities reject results that do not match the functional profile.

Genuine losses exist — what proves them?

Plenty of losses are real: start-up phases, heavy depreciation, currency swings, lost orders or an industry down-cycle. The line between genuine and transfer-pricing losses is contemporaneous evidence: the business plan and forecasts from investment time, documented explanations of market movements, independent industry data showing unrelated competitors also losing money, and transfer pricing files prepared on time each year. The fatal weakness is documentation ‘rebuilt’ after an audit decision arrives — timestamps betray it. If losses stem from a group decision (for example holding prices low to win market share), that decision should be recorded as a time-bound strategy with an analysis of when break-even is expected.

Consequences when the explanation fails

Where authorities conclude related-party prices are not arm’s length, they adjust revenue or costs, assess additional CIT on the adjusted profit, plus late-payment interest and penalties under the Law on Tax Administration 108/2025/QH15. For a loss-maker, the adjustment typically wipes out carried-forward losses, so later years lose their loss ‘shield’ even if no cash is paid immediately — damage that stays invisible until the first profitable year. The group may also face double taxation if the counterparty’s country makes no corresponding adjustment; the treaty MAP is then the only exit. The cheapest defence remains a proper transfer pricing file prepared every year, before losses become ‘many consecutive years’.

Frequently Asked Questions

What transfer pricing risks face an FDI company with consecutive loss years?

The risk is audit and deemed profit adjustment: authorities test sales prices, purchase prices, management fees, royalties and related-party interest against the company’s actual functions. A transfer pricing conclusion erases or cuts the losses, with back tax, late-payment interest and penalties under tax administration rules.

What do tax authorities suspect when a loss-making company keeps expanding?

They suspect profit is being shifted out of Vietnam through related-party prices: an independent business rarely keeps funding a chronic loss-maker. Expanding while losing strengthens the ‘loss by price structure’ hypothesis over the ‘loss by market’ one, unless contemporaneous market evidence proves the contrary.

How can we prove the losses are genuine?

With contemporaneous files: forecasts and business plans from the investment stage, industry data showing independent companies suffering similar losses, explanations of input cost movements, and timely transfer pricing documentation whose functions–risks analysis is consistent with the loss result. Documents rebuilt after an audit starts carry very little weight.


Related articles

Reviewed by the Legal Practice Group – FLAT LAW FIRM

This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.