CUP — the comparable uncontrolled price method — is the most direct transfer pricing method: it takes the actual price of an equivalent transaction between independent parties as the yardstick. It is also the hardest to use, because the comparable transaction must be so similar that every remaining difference can be adjusted with reliable data.
When is CUP at its strongest?
CUP is strongest where the product or service trades on an open market, or where the company itself has similar transactions with independent parties. Three classic cases: exchange-quoted commodities (metals, agricultural goods, oil) where the related-party price can be matched to the same delivery period; related-party loan interest compared with an equivalent independent bank loan; and royalties where the company also licenses to independent third parties on similar terms. Within the five-method system carried forward in Decree 255/2026/ND-CP (with RPM, the cost plus method, TNMM and profit split), CUP is regarded as the most direct approach where comparables are truly equivalent — and the first method auditors ask about when a public reference price exists.
Conditions: comparability and adjustability
Two core conditions: the comparable must be genuinely comparable, and material differences must be reliably adjustable. Comparability is tested across product characteristics, contractual terms, economic conditions, business strategies and the parties’ functions. Differences in volume, payment terms, delivery terms and geography must each be quantifiable and adjustable with dependable data; if one material difference cannot be adjusted, the transaction loses comparable status and CUP collapses. Internal CUPs (the company has both related and independent versions of the same transaction) usually persuade more than external ones because operating conditions match. Conversely, taking a ‘reference price’ from a very different market with no adjustments is the easiest CUP to have rejected.
Where comparable data lives, and how to document it
External CUP sources include exchange quotations, published price lists, commercial databases and customs statistics for similar goods. Decree 255/2026/ND-CP is notable for tightening the hierarchy of benchmarking data sources, so the file should state why this source was chosen and others rejected. A good CUP file contains: a description of the tested transaction, the selection criteria for comparables, a table of identified differences and how each was adjusted, and the resulting price range. Where independent prices scatter too widely, the transactions are probably not comparable enough — moving to TNMM on margins is usually more audit-resistant.
Frequently Asked Questions
When does the comparable uncontrolled price (CUP) method apply?
Where a sufficiently reliable equivalent independent transaction exists: exchange-quoted goods, a loan that can be matched to an equivalent bank loan for interest, or the company’s own similar transactions with independent parties. CUP is the most direct of the five related-party pricing methods under Decree 255/2026/ND-CP.
What are the conditions for using this method?
The comparable must match on product, contract terms, economic conditions and functions, and every remaining material difference must be adjustable with reliable data. One material difference that cannot be adjusted disqualifies the comparable and with it the CUP.
Where can market prices for comparison be found?
From commodity exchange quotations, published price lists, commercial databases, customs data and — best of all — the company’s own similar independent transactions (internal CUP). The file must record the hierarchy and reasons for choosing data sources as Decree 255/2026/ND-CP requires.
Related articles
- Special Consumption Tax on Sugar-Sweetened Beverages from 1 January 2027: Scope and Rates
- Amended Customs Law (Effective 1 March 2027): Key Changes for Import-Export Businesses
- Personal Income Tax on Inherited Assets and Gifts in Vietnam
- Leveraging New-Generation FTA Tariff Preferences (EVFTA, CPTPP) for Vietnamese Exports
- Temporary Admission for Exhibitions and Construction Machinery: Temporary Admission Records and Tax Refunds
This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.

