When a contract with a foreign partner ends in argument, the last money leaving Vietnam usually carries the name compensation or penalty. That name decides whether contractor tax is withheld, but the tax authority reads substance rather than names: does the money buy a service, or does it fill a loss. Separating those two things is the entire content of the problem.
The substance principle: genuine damages are not the price of a service
Contractor tax is designed to strike a foreign contractor income from supplying goods, services, royalties and capital in Vietnam under the frame of the Corporate Income Tax Law 67/2025/QH15, Decree 320/2025/ND-CP and Circular 20/2026/TT-BTC. Damages under Articles 360 and 361 of the Civil Code 91/2015/QH13 and agreed contractual penalties are not the price of any goods or services supplied: the recipient sells nothing further to the payer, they are merely restored to the financial position as if the breach had not occurred. Lacking the consideration element of a supply transaction, genuine compensation and penalties sit outside contractor tax scope.
For that conclusion to hold, the loss and the clause must be genuine. The file needs the penalty clause or compensation basis in the contract, a record or demand letter identifying the breach and the concrete loss, and proportionality between the payment and the proven loss or the agreed penalty, which in commercial relations is capped at 8 percent of the value of the breached obligation part under Article 301 of the Commercial Law 36/2005/QH11. A round compensation figure exactly equal to one month of service fees, with no loss record, is a file inviting the tax authority questions.
Disguised payments: when the word compensation covers a service fee
Conversely, the market holds many payments named compensation whose substance is money for something done. An early termination fee under which the partner must hand over data, support migration and maintain services through a transition period is payment for those services and bears contractor tax at the service rates of 5 percent income tax and 5 percent value added tax. A discount the foreign partner grants into the final payment period and recovers as an equal compensation line elsewhere is likewise looked through in form and taxed as the hidden service revenue it is.
The third grey point is late payment interest arising from the same matter. Unlike damages, late payment interest carries the nature of income from being paid late, and the careful treatment is to separate it as its own line in the settlement agreement, declared by the nature of the income attached to the original contract, rather than wrapping it into one compensation figure that then gets disputed as a whole. A good settlement agreement always separates three lines: compensation and penalties outside tax scope, payment for handover services taxed as services, and late payment interest handled on its own nature.
When the foreign side pays: the reverse direction and the Vietnamese side duty
Half the cases run in the reverse direction: the foreign partner compensates the Vietnamese company for late delivery or contract cancellation. That receipt has nothing to do with contractor tax, which only processes money paid out to foreign contractors, but it is other income of the Vietnamese company for domestic corporate income tax and needs the same loss file to prove its nature at finalisation. Companies suffering twice from the same file defect, a missing loss record, is a real pattern in inspection periods.
Because the in-or-out of contractor tax decision rests on evidence rather than the payment label, the right time to build the file is when the settlement agreement is drafted, not when the tax authority asks three years later. A settlement annex recording the breach basis, the loss computation, the penalty clause invoked and the separation from every remaining service duty will let the outside-scope conclusion stand on its own in any inspection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is contract compensation paid to a foreign partner subject to tax?
Genuine damages and genuine contractual penalties do not bear contractor tax, because they are not the price of goods or services supplied but loss restoration under Articles 360 and 361 of the Civil Code 91/2015/QH13 and the contract penalty clause. The conclusion holds only where the file proves the breach, the concrete loss and the proportionality of the payment. Any payment named compensation whose substance pays for something performed is taxed by its service substance instead.
Is penalty for contract breach subject to foreign contractor tax?
No, where it is a genuine penalty arising from an agreed penalty clause in the contract and attached to an identifiable breach; in commercial relations the penalty is capped at 8 percent of the value of the breached obligation part under Article 301 of the Commercial Law 36/2005/QH11. A penalty sits outside contractor tax for the same reason as damages: no goods or services are supplied in exchange for it. Keep the penalty clause, the breach record and the penalty decision to prove the payment when the tax authority inspects the expense.
How are compensation and service payments distinguished?
The test is consideration: if the foreign party must do or supply something in exchange for the money, such as handing over data, supporting migration, maintaining services through a transition or continuing supply after a termination notice, it is a service payment bearing contractor tax of 5 percent income tax and 5 percent value added tax. If the money only fills a loss already suffered from a breach and buys nothing further, it is compensation outside scope. A settlement should separate the two lines and split late payment interest out as a third line handled on its own nature.
Related articles
- MNE group transfer pricing policies in Vietnam
- Benchmarking in TP documentation: data sources
- Transfer pricing for parent management fees
- Transfer pricing audits at FDI firms: process and company rights
- TP profit adjustments: when do tax authorities make deemed assessments?
This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.

