Tax

Fined for Missing TP Documentation Despite Small Related-Party Deals: Any Exemption?

A vintage office setup featuring a stack of documents, orange lamp, and classic wooden furniture.

Many small companies believe a related-party transaction “worth only a few billion dong” sits beyond the reach of transfer pricing documentation, and are fined on exactly that belief: Vietnamese law sets the documentation exemption by the period’s total revenue and total related-party transaction value, not transaction by transaction, and separates three distinct duties — declaring related-party transactions, preparing and keeping the pricing file, and respecting the arm’s length principle in the price itself. Qualifying for the documentation exemption (under Decree 132/2020/ND-CP for earlier periods and Decree 255/2026/ND-CP for periods from 1 July 2026) removes only the second duty; the other two remain fully intact, even for very small transactions. This article clarifies who is truly exempt, when a missing file is genuinely fined, and how much value late preparation still holds.

How the exemption thresholds actually work

The most common exemption applies where, in a tax period, the company’s total revenue is under VND 50 billion and simultaneously the total value of related-party transactions arising in the period does not exceed VND 30 billion — both conditions together, with the total counted across all related-party transactions of the period, not per contract. A company with VND 40 billion revenue but related-party loans and purchases aggregating VND 35 billion must still prepare the full file. Companies under an advance pricing agreement (APA) are exempt for the covered scope under its own mechanism.

Exemption is re-tested every period: being exempt this period guarantees nothing for the next, since revenue and transaction values move year to year. Companies near the boundary need a per-period tracker of both metrics, because the costliest mistake is believing oneself exempt in a period where the second limb was in fact exceeded.

Three separate duties: exemption from the file is not exemption from everything

Duty one, declaration: every company with related-party transactions must declare them on the appendix form accompanying the corporate income tax finalisation return, including companies exempt from documentation — exemption from the file never means exemption from declaration, and non-declaration is fined independently. Duty two, preparing and keeping the pricing file: only this duty carries the exemption thresholds; companies outside the exemption must prepare the file at the prescribed levels and produce it on request during inspection. Duty three, arm’s length pricing: even where both detailed declaration relief and documentation exemption applied, the price used in a related-party transaction must still follow the arm’s length principle, and the authority may still re-price a specific transaction on inspection.

The consequence of merging these duties is a company genuinely exempt from documentation still being fined for non-declaration, or worse, being re-priced on a small transaction whose market evidence was never assembled because of the belief that “small means fully exempt”.

How the fine works, and what late preparation still buys

Failing to prepare, keep or produce a required pricing file is an administrative violation under the frame of Decree 125/2020/ND-CP, separate from price adjustment: even where the actual transaction price is arm’s length, the file failure remains an independently finable procedural violation, though the tax adjustment is nil. Conversely, where the price is adjusted, the collection and incorrect-declaration penalty run on that adjustment, plus the file violation where present — two parallel layers the company must separate when explaining.

Late preparation still has real value on three fronts: on penalties, voluntarily completing the file before an inspection decision is a self-remedial act recognised as a mitigating circumstance under general administrative-sanction principles; on pricing, a late file with serious price analysis remains the main evidence against assessment on the inspection team’s data, albeit with less weight than a timely file; and prospectively, it locks in a timely-preparation routine for later periods. What late preparation cannot do is erase a completed procedural violation — but the distance between “fined with mitigation” and “fined in full plus adverse re-pricing” is large enough that every company discovering a missing file should prepare it immediately rather than wait for inspection.

FAQ

How much is the fine?

Documentation is not tested per transaction but on the period’s total related-party transaction value and total revenue: a company is exempt from preparing the file where total revenue for the period is under VND 50 billion and total related-party transactions in the period do not exceed VND 30 billion, under Decree 132/2020/ND-CP (periods from 1 July 2026: Decree 255/2026/ND-CP). A transaction of a few billion inside an over-threshold total needs a file like any other.

What is the exemption threshold?

No, if the company genuinely meets both conditions of the exemption case for that period — no documentation duty arises, so there is no failure-to-prepare act to fine. But the authority will re-test the exemption conditions: if actual related-party transactions exceeded VND 30 billion or revenue exceeded VND 50 billion, the exemption collapses and the missing file is sanctioned in full. A company confident of exemption should keep its two-metric computation for the period as evidence.

Does supplementary preparation reduce the fine?

The two layers separate: an arm’s length price means no tax adjustment, but failure to prepare a required file remains an independently finable administrative violation under Decree 125/2020/ND-CP as a procedural breach. If the price is also wrong, the company bears both the pricing collection and the file penalty. A correct price therefore saves the tax part, not the procedural part.

Can I file a complaint?

Yes, on three fronts: voluntarily completing the file before an inspection decision is a mitigating circumstance in administrative sanctioning; a supplementary file with serious price analysis remains evidence against adverse re-pricing; and it establishes timely preparation for later periods. Late preparation cannot erase the procedural violation that already occurred, but it materially reduces total exposure compared with being caught in inspection.

Related articles

Reviewed by the Legal Practice Group – FLAT LAW FIRM

This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.