The principal purpose test (PPT) changed the basic assumption of treaty planning: it is no longer enough that a structure formally fits a treaty’s words. If obtaining the treaty benefit was one of the principal purposes of the arrangement, the benefit can be denied — and holding structures routed through third countries into Vietnam sit squarely in its line of sight.
What PPT is and where it comes from
The PPT is the minimum-standard anti-abuse rule of the OECD Multilateral Instrument (MLI), which Vietnam signed and applies to its covered tax treaties. In substance: a treaty benefit shall not be granted in respect of an item of income if it is reasonable to conclude that obtaining the benefit was one of the principal purposes of an arrangement or transaction that resulted in that benefit — unless granting it would accord with the object and purpose of the treaty. Two features matter for practice: the test looks at purposes (a facts-and-reasons inquiry), and the burden dynamics favour the authority once the structure has little visible substance. Vietnam’s domestic anti-avoidance and substance-over-form rules under the Law on Tax Administration 108/2025/QH15 reinforce the same direction at the payment point.
What real substance looks like
Substance is a set of facts, not a certificate: decision-makers who are real people, resident where the company is, actually deciding; an office and operating costs proportionate to the holding function; own bank activity and accounting; a documented commercial rationale for the jurisdiction (regional management, financing centre, listing or investor requirements) that predates the tax question; and a holding period and behaviour consistent with a genuine investor. The weakest files are those where every element was assembled in the month the structure was challenged. Groups should also align the treaty analysis with transfer pricing: a holding company claiming large benefits while performing no functions invites attack from both directions at once.
Practical consequences at the Vietnamese payment point
PPT is applied where money leaves Vietnam: withholding relief on dividends within the applicable rules, interest and royalties under treaties can be refused if the recipient structure fails the test — converting an expected 0% or reduced rate into the full domestic contractor tax, with the Vietnamese payer exposed for under-withholding. The consequences are therefore negotiated at the SPA and loan-documentation level too: tax indemnities and gross-up clauses should anticipate a PPT denial. Before restructuring into a new holding jurisdiction, groups should model the benefit under a PPT-denied scenario; if the deal only works with the treaty benefit, the structure is the risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the treaty anti-abuse rule (PPT)?
PPT (principal purpose test) is the anti-abuse rule of the Multilateral Instrument (MLI): treaty benefits are denied where obtaining the benefit was one of the principal purposes of an arrangement, unless granting it accords with the treaty’s object and purpose. Vietnam applies the MLI to its covered treaties.
What must FDI firms do to avoid being treated as abusing the treaty?
Build genuine economic substance in the holding structure: real people and decisions, own office and costs, documented commercial reasons for the structure beyond tax, and a holding history consistent with the investment. Paper substance assembled afterwards rarely survives review.
Are third-country structures affected?
Yes — third-country holding structures are exactly what PPT targets. The closer the holding company is to a conduit (funds and decisions merely passing through), the higher the risk treaty benefits on dividends, interest and royalties are denied at the Vietnamese payment point.
Related articles
- Incorrect VAT invoices: how to adjust or replace
- VAT on promotional goods and gifts of FDI firms
- Domestic Law vs Treaty Conflicts: Case Law and Practice
- Criminal Tax Risk: When Does Evasion Become a Crime?
- Appealing a Tax Assessment: The 90-Day Deadline and Dossier
This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.

