A Japanese manufacturer in Hai Phong is assessed foreign contractor tax on royalty payments even though the Vietnam–Japan double tax treaty caps source-country taxation below the rate the tax authority is applying. When domestic law and a treaty conflict, which instrument prevails and what must the company actually do is the subject of this topic.
Legal basis at the time of writing
Article 6 of Law on Treaties 89/2016/QH13 provides that where a domestic legal document (other than the Constitution) and a treaty to which Vietnam is a party regulate the same matter differently, the treaty applies. Law on Tax Administration 108/2025/QH15 (effective 1 July 2026, replacing Law 38/2019/QH14) carries this principle into tax administration and the advance pricing agreement (APA) mechanism. The current contractor-tax framework is Law on CIT 67/2025/QH15 with Decree 320/2025/ND-CP and Circular 20/2026/TT-BTC, after the CIT part of Circular 103/2014/TT-BTC was repealed from 12 March 2026.
Practice: the treaty wins on paper, procedure wins in real life
In principle the treaty prevails. But the tax authority does not apply it automatically: the company must file a notification dossier for treaty relief before the payment period, with the partner’s certificate of residence. Without the dossier, assessment under domestic law is procedurally correct, leaving only a complaint or the mutual agreement procedure (MAP) between the two competent authorities. In practice disputes rarely concern the priority principle itself; they turn on how treaty terms such as permanent establishment and beneficial owner are interpreted, where Vietnamese authorities read them more strictly than the treaty partner.
Case law and reference value in Vietnam
Vietnam does not follow binding common-law precedent; published case law selected by the Council of Judges of the Supreme People’s Court is studied and applied by courts, but very few published cases deal directly with tax-treaty conflicts. References carrying more practical weight are guidance letters of the Ministry of Finance and the tax authorities and complaint decisions, although none of these are sources of law. When citing them, companies should state their reference nature and not present them as binding legal basis. Where conflicting interpretations by two tax authorities cause genuine double taxation, MAP is the only official channel to eliminate it, usually with a three-year filing window under each treaty.
Recommended actions
1. Review every outbound payment under both layers — current domestic law and the corresponding treaty article — and record the differences in a single comparison table.
2. Complete the treaty-relief notification dossier and the residence certificate before the payment period; late filing is the most common reason treaty benefits are lost.
3. If assessed contrary to the treaty, run two tracks in parallel: a domestic complaint to preserve deadlines and a MAP request through the competent authority.
Businesses facing a similar situation should speak with counsel early to settle the approach before signing documents or filing applications.
Frequently asked questions
When Vietnamese law conflicts with a treaty, which applies?
The treaty applies. Article 6 of Law on Treaties 89/2016/QH13 states that where a domestic document (other than the Constitution) and a treaty regulate the same matter differently, the treaty prevails. In tax matters, however, the company must complete notification procedures and prove the treaty conditions; the authority does not apply the treaty automatically.
How do tax authorities handle this in practice?
The tax authority examines the treaty-relief notification dossier together with the residence certificate; a complete dossier gets the treaty rate, an incomplete one is assessed under domestic law. Interpretation disputes (permanent establishment, beneficial owner) usually go through a complaint or the mutual agreement procedure (MAP).
Are there any precedents to refer to?
Published Vietnamese case law directly on tax-treaty conflicts is very scarce and is not binding as in common-law systems. Practical references are guidance letters of the Ministry of Finance and tax authorities and complaint decisions — useful for orientation but not sources of law, and they should be cited as such.
What should a business do?
Compare domestic law and the treaty side by side for each payment, complete the treaty dossier before paying, and if assessed contrary to the treaty, complain domestically while requesting MAP within the treaty’s time limit (usually three years). Do not wait until collection begins to obtain the residence certificate.
Related articles
- VAT Refunds for Businesses With High Export Revenue for Over Five Consecutive Years: Fast-Track Refund Conditions
- Non-Creditable and Non-Refundable Input VAT That Must Be Expensed: Identifying Correctly to Avoid CIT Risks
- VAT for Domestic Digital Platform Businesses: Vietnamese Digital Service Enterprises Invoicing Global Customers
- Input VAT Credit for Goods Imported Through Third Parties and Entrusted Import: Tax Payment Proof by Representatives
- VAT on Real Estate Transfers: Taxable Price and Deductible Land-Use Levies Under the New Rules
This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.

