Tax

Digital Transactions (Software, Licenses) with Affiliates: Pricing Them

A programmer working on code with dual monitors and a laptop in a dimly lit room.

Software and digital licence transactions — ERP, production management software, SaaS platforms, data licences — are the intangible transactions Vietnamese transfer pricing is tightening fastest, because they touch three fronts at once: is the related-party price arm’s length, is the payment a royalty or a service fee for contractor-tax withholding, and is the cost deductible for corporate income tax. Unlike trademark royalties (EXP-5993) or management fees (EXP-5992), software enjoys a rare advantage: many products are sold to thousands of independent customers on published price lists, creating direct comparables other intangibles lack. The frame is Decree 255/2026/ND-CP for periods from 1 July 2026 (earlier periods: Decree 132/2020/ND-CP), while the payment’s character drives contractor tax under the current frame (the corporate income tax part of Circular 103/2014/TT-BTC was abolished from 12 March 2026, replaced by Corporate Income Tax Law 67/2025/QH15, Decree 320/2025/ND-CP and Circular 20/2026/TT-BTC).

Pricing: start from what is actually being licensed

Classification decides the whole method. Case one, standard packaged software sold widely: the subsidiary buys use rights in a product identical to what the supplier (even a related distributor) sells to independent customers — a direct comparison situation using published price lists and discount policies by user or licence count; the related price is defensible inside the price and discount frame applied to independents on equivalent terms. Case two, software or platforms deeply customised for the subsidiary or jointly developed: no list price exists to compare, and the analysis moves to the functions each side performs (who develops, who operates, who bears data and security risk), potentially to residual profit split where both sides contribute unique intangibles.

Case three is the most misclassified: user-based SaaS subscriptions. Sellers often present them as a “licence fee” while the contract’s substance is an access service to a platform the foreign side operates — misclassification here distorts both the pricing method and the contractor-tax regime, so the contract must separate the software use right, the operation and support service, and the implementation and customisation components from signing.

Contractor tax: why the payment’s label decides the obligation

An outbound software payment can be a royalty in character (paying for use of an intangible) or a service fee (paying for operation, support, hosting), and the two characters bear different contractor-tax mechanics for both value added tax and corporate income tax under the current frame set out above. The practical consequence: a contract bundling “licence and services” unsplit invites reclassification on the unfavourable side, and the withholding and remittance arrears, with late-payment charges, fall on the Vietnamese payer.

Companies should determine each component’s character proactively in the contract, state it in the payment terms, and align invoicing documents with the group accordingly. Where the group uses a global template contract without component splits, a Vietnam annex is the tool to fix this without renegotiating the whole framework agreement.

The pricing file for software: what must be on hand

A sound file contains: the supplier’s published price list and discount policy for independent customers at signing (the central evidence for standard software); an analysis of actual users and licences against the numbers charged — inspectors commonly find fees computed on licence counts far beyond actual usage needs, and the excess is removed as a cost not serving the business; a functional analysis for the customised parts; and contractor-tax files matching each payment component.

One under-noticed practical point: software fees computed on revenue or growing user counts must be reviewed periodically like every related transaction, because changing usage changes the reasonableness of the total even at an unchanged unit price. Fee caps and annual review mechanisms in the contract are the cheapest way to prevent future disputes.

FAQ

How are digital license prices benchmarked?

It depends on the transaction type: for widely sold standard packaged software, the comparable uncontrolled price method using published price lists and discount policies for independent customers is the most direct; for deeply customised or jointly developed software with no market price, a functional analysis is required, possibly with residual profit split where both sides contribute unique intangibles, under Decree 255/2026/ND-CP (earlier periods: Decree 132/2020/ND-CP).

How is the CUP method applied?

Because the two characters bear different contractor-tax mechanics for both value added tax and corporate income tax, under the current frame of Corporate Income Tax Law 67/2025/QH15, Decree 320/2025/ND-CP and Circular 20/2026/TT-BTC (the corporate income tax part of Circular 103/2014/TT-BTC was abolished from 12 March 2026). A contract bundling both components unsplit invites unfavourable reclassification, and the Vietnamese payer bears the withholding arrears.

Where is benchmarking data obtained?

Yes, for the corresponding part: charged licence counts must match the subsidiary’s actual usage needs. Fees computed on licence counts far beyond actual users and departments in use are commonly removed from deductible costs as expenses not serving the enterprise’s activity, and challenged in related-party pricing. Companies should review usage annually and right-size the licence scope accordingly.

What documentation is needed?

The decisive file sits on the Vietnam side: the contract and annex splitting components, payment records, the independent price list evidencing the fee level, the functional analysis for customised parts, and the contractor-tax withholding file. A transfer pricing inspection is run by the Vietnamese authority on the file the company must supply, so a foreign group’s refusal to share independent customer pricing data is a risk the subsidiary must solve beforehand by contract clause, not at the inspection table.

Related articles

Reviewed by the Legal Practice Group – FLAT LAW FIRM

This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.