Tax

Royalties at 8% of Revenue Deemed Unreasonably High: Negotiating with Tax Office

Three business professionals in discussion over a contract in a modern office setting.

Whether an 8% of revenue royalty is high or low can only be judged against two things: the rates independent parties pay for equivalent brand and technology rights, and the value the parent brand actually creates in the Vietnamese market. A parent management fee charged on revenue and rejected wholesale is the benefit-test story of services (EXP-5952); royalties are a different story — the subject is an intangible, and the analytical frame under Decree 255/2026/ND-CP (earlier periods: Decree 132/2020/ND-CP) turns on the DEMPE functions (development, enhancement, maintenance, protection and exploitation of the intangible) and on independent licensing data. Successful negotiation over the 8% does not start with asking for a reduction; it starts with proving the parent brand genuinely “works” in Vietnam.

A reasonable rate comes from data, not impressions

Commercial licensing databases (the independent licence-agreement databases used in international transfer pricing analysis) allow filtering licence contracts by industry and region for brand and know-how rights and extracting the range of rates independents accept. The company should present that range with its filtering criteria and difference adjustments: exclusive or non-exclusive, territory, term, and whether the licensee also receives marketing support or must build the market itself. An 8% sitting inside the adjusted interquartile range is a wholly different negotiating position from an 8% supported only by the intra-group contract.

In parallel, unbundle what the 8% contains: if it also packages support services, software use or distribution rights, the authority will treat the whole as a royalty and attack it once. Separating each line and pricing each by its own method clears the ground for negotiation.

What the parent brand contributes in Vietnam: the DEMPE analysis

DEMPE asks: who develops the brand (R&D and creative investment), who enhances and maintains it in the Vietnamese market (local marketing spend borne by the subsidiary or by the parent), who protects it (registration, anti-infringement), and who exploits it. If the Vietnamese subsidiary has borne most market-building marketing cost for years, the authority’s argument — that part of the brand value in Vietnam was created by the subsidiary itself, so the royalty must be lower or the subsidiary compensated — has an analytical basis and must be answered with both sides’ spending figures, not assertions.

A strong negotiation file contains: the parent’s global brand investment history directly relevant to products sold in Vietnam, the market costs borne by each side per year, and evidence that consumers and distribution channels in Vietnam price the product because of the parent brand rather than local factors.

Negotiation and complaint: the two levels

At the working level with the inspection team, the realistic goal is narrowing the adjusted portion and the years applied: file the benchmark report and DEMPE analysis early, before the draft minutes close. At the complaint level — to the issuing tax authority, then the superior level or the administrative court — the same analytical dossier is used, with one difference: the weight of the independent expert signing the report becomes the decisive factor.

A frequently forgotten companion tax: royalties paid abroad also fall under the foreign contractor tax mechanism in its current frame (Corporate Income Tax Law 67/2025/QH15, Decree 320/2025/ND-CP and Circular 20/2026/TT-BTC; the CIT part of Circular 103/2014/TT-BTC was abolished from 12 March 2026) — a transfer pricing negotiation that changes the transaction value also changes this tax base, and the two files must be handled consistently.

FAQ

What royalty rate is reasonable?

No statutory standard rate exists; a reasonable rate is one inside the value range of comparable independent licence agreements (same industry, same intangible type, same exclusivity and territory conditions) drawn from commercial licensing databases, after difference adjustments. Whether 8% survives depends entirely on that comparison range and on the brand-contribution analysis in Vietnam.

Where is benchmarking data obtained?

From international commercial licence-agreement databases used in transfer pricing analysis, filtered by industry, intangible type, geography and licence conditions; supplemented by any independent licence contracts the group or the company has itself signed with third parties. The benchmark report must disclose filtering criteria and the reasons for excluding each unsuitable contract.

What does the parent brand contribute?

Under DEMPE analysis the parent brand contributes the value created by developing and owning the intangible at group level; but if the Vietnamese subsidiary bears most local market-building and brand-maintenance cost, part of the brand value in Vietnam is treated as created by the subsidiary — the very basis authorities use to press the royalty rate down. Both sides’ marketing spend by year is the decisive evidence.

Where do I complain about an adjustment decision?

Complain to the tax authority that issued the adjustment and collection decision; if dissatisfied, complain to the superior tax authority or sue in the administrative court. The complaint file should attach the independent expert’s benchmark report and DEMPE analysis, because at this level the argument is about data and method.

Related articles

Reviewed by the Legal Practice Group – FLAT LAW FIRM

This legal analysis has been verified against current Vietnamese regulations and cross-border FDI transaction practices by the attorneys at FLAT LAW FIRM.